When and why do men initiate force?
Posted by Wonky 10 years, 9 months ago to Philosophy
Pure inquiry here. I just want to hear some opinions. My apologies if this topic is explored in another post.
You type: | You see: |
---|---|
*italics* | italics |
**bold** | bold |
While we're very happy to have you in the Gulch and appreciate your wanting to fully engage, some things in the Gulch (e.g. voting, links in comments) are a privilege, not a right. To get you up to speed as quickly as possible, we've provided two options for earning these privileges.
When other people don't fall into line, agree that it is the right and good way, begin to do it that way, and start working on convincing others, the original source will sometimes try convincing the non-complyers using positive and negative methods: arguments, rewards, penalties. At this point, I thin the original source is still convinced that his way is best, and he just has to find the right method of convincing others. Somewhere in there, he stumbles on/has suggested to him/ thinks up the use of force.
Surely, he thinks, once people are forced to do the right thing, they will realize the validity of his point and come to it willingly - then, he can stop forcing them to it.
But there is always some number of contrarians who don't want to do anything someone else has suggested, or some thoughtful people who see the proposed action as, bluntly, dumb [typo: dung] and some who just want to be left alone. And then there are the children of both those who comply and those who do not, who have their own opinion and "have" to be convinced.
It never ends, so the force can never end, just because some guy wants his own way and is willing to go all out to get it, and get everyone to agree with him, too.
Particularly unfounded emotionally derived fear.
We do follow the Rand [and others] convention that "man" = male and female, but I wanted to be damn sure before I responded.
ok?
What is the one way to stop them? On a personal level, total "indifference" would be my best answer (at present), but I'm interested in yours.
Load more comments...