Hi. My name is... Robert Smith
Posted by Boborobdos 12 years ago to The Gulch: Introductions
I'm very happy to have landed in the Gulch... I hope to get some insights for when I watch and discuss the movie.
While we're very happy to have you in the Gulch and appreciate your wanting to fully engage, some things in the Gulch (e.g. voting, links in comments) are a privilege, not a right. To get you up to speed as quickly as possible, we've provided two options for earning these privileges.
Previous comments... You are currently on page 9.
Rob
Corporate employees ALWAYS fall into it.
I'll take my chances with someone other than the fat cats.
Rob
http://www.suu.edu/faculty/baker_j/artic...
Fat cat sucks all he can for himself, his cronies, and the stockholders.
Civil servant is pretty much on a fixed salary, and under little pressure to "make money." There is little personal incentive for them to deny care.
Rob
because both control the doctor patient relationship
Ahhhhh, so might one conclude that your "faith" is put in some fat cat in a limo who has given instructions to someone without a medical degree to tell your doctor what they can do for you?
What a system.
Rob
"Intelligence" is quite interesting, but the most insightful book I've seen is, "The Bell Curve."
It's also very relative. My dog was a puppy in a Spanish household. He understands Spanish. I struggle with the English I was born into. The dog just picked it up. It isn't conversational, but he does listen and understand commands.
So, in the context of language is my dog smarter than I am? (Don't need to answer that.)
In fact I absolutely marvel at folks who speak more than one language, particularly if they learned another language as an adult.
Rob
ve used that to my advantage as a prod to find smarter and less sweat inducing ways to accomplish things.
In many ways, I sympathize with the father in your story. But his daughter might well have learned a valuable lesson from her $800/mo job. That of work ethic and also that of the need to better her qualifications for better possibilities.
But all of that said, you can beat laziness. We did it in the 90's for a short while, by reducing, eliminating, and making it tougher to live on just a welfare basis and income. Large numbers of previous 'welfare' (lazy) families got up and went to work and drastically improved theirs and their families' lives and contributions.
But the welfare system has gradually crept back in and under Obama it has grown dramatically.
All of us in the Western World are in the fight of our lives against 'collectivism' and 'socialism'.
But Atlas and AR can be used to illustrate that we will win eventually. The producers, when driven far enough will find their own Galt's Gulch.
That's a fact.
Rob
http://channel.nationalgeographic.com/ch...
Rob
Actually corporations export the jobs.
Rob
It's the same force that is part of our society that builds roads, schools, and defends us. We are a better society if more folks can work. They work much better without parts of them being cut off to cope with diabetes. For something like TB it isn't a "choice" of lifestyle or anything like that. It's simply the chance of encountering someone with the disease, which is greatly reduced when folks get treatment.
"You're also paying whether you need the services or not."
You need the services unless you live totally away from everything. Someone with untreated sleep apnea is worse than a drunk on the road. That's generally not something picked up in an ER and they get sent home with the equipment.
Rob
But you miss the point. You're in the system by coercive force. You're also paying whether you need the services or not. Maybe I'd rather spend my money and effort living a healthy and safe life, thus avoiding the need for those services. I can buy catastrophic insurance for much less than a 'pay for everything' policy.
I think you also miss the point of gambling. Purchasing Health Ins. is your bet against the Ins. Co. that you're going to get sick and they're betting that you won't. It simply is not that difficult to prepare your self for the dangers of life. I can and have managed my own risk assessments my whole life. I have no interest in others trying to do it for me.
Doctors are and always have been as human as the rest of us. They were not altruistic angels. They were in medicine for the same reason I was in science and engineering, personal choice. The reason they don't come to your house anymore is as much about govt regulation and interference as it is about the sheer numbers of needs to be met.
Your arguments are naive at best.
KYFHO
So we have on one hand the choice of "going Galt" and on the other hand dealing with what creates the least burden on us. Considering that Objectivists have almost no perceptible voice or sway in the political arena and the country is too far gone to try to save now, what is our next move? Is it possible to check out of the system by using something like bitcoin or a decentralized currency that can't be tracked by "The Man" or do we have to hide in a valley somewhere and start over?
Any withholding taxes sent in their name becomes part of their total, and there is no theft when they receive monies deposited in their account. The deposits were made, and forfeited by the identity thief.
Rob
So far, everyone understands where you are coming from. Congratulations!
When, and if, the Congress convenes in some grassy field, they will be sitting under an OSHA free sky. As of now, they are using a building that adheres to OSHA guidelines...proved by your own findings.
Other laws were not part of the discussion, and you are trying to jump track...to avoid the inevitable head-on collision.
Formidable... Now make sure you recognize this as the most pleasing meaning... :)
Wrong way to think about it in my humble opinion. If you are in the system you aren't gambling. You are guaranteed coverage.
If you are betting on yourself you are one accident or stroke away from being wiped out and being on the dole yourself, unless you are one of the 1% that doesn't have to worry about such things.
Back years ago doctors were in medicine to help people, not to get rich. If he came to your house (pretty much only in the realm of concierge medicine these days) to check up on someone who was ill often all that was expected was a meal and maybe some firewood next time you came to town with the wagon.
Being a doctor then was a calling, not a license to make money. When it became that it started going down the financial rat hole it is now.
BTW, Catholic Hospitals are still around, as are the Shiners.
Rob
Load more comments...