[Ask the Gulch] Is Learning an act of consumption?
Posted by rbroberg 8 years, 4 months ago to Ask the Gulch
While we're very happy to have you in the Gulch and appreciate your wanting to fully engage, some things in the Gulch (e.g. voting, links in comments) are a privilege, not a right. To get you up to speed as quickly as possible, we've provided two options for earning these privileges.
Literally, to consume something is to use it up until gone. So learning does not consume knowledge. While the knowledge some people learn may well be wasted on those individuals, even then, unless they are the sole being on Earth in possession of that knowledge and they die, it is not lost because others know the same things and generally that knowledge would be available in books, or other media.
Even something like a medication, which is consumed in the traditional sense, may be trivially cheap to manufacture, but what users are really "consuming" is all the research that went into discovering the medicine and proving it safe and effective.
What's being consumed when someone takes medicine? Is it the chemicals in the drug, which get consumed by chemical reactions in the body and excreted? Or is it the knowledge attained in developing the drug, which is never used up no matter how much medicine is consumed?
Learning does not happen at the same time of consumming content. Those are two different acts.
Paying for a service is an act of consumption.
The real question is whether or not it is an investment. Is it an act of pure consumption with no appreciable output, or is it a tool that leads to results later on down the line. For many (unfortunately) information goes in, but doesn't really effect any real output or change.
But consume doesn't necessarily mean to destroy or use up, it also means to take in, eat, drink, digest, as well as buy. Information can be consumed and still used by others.
The same thing is not true with consumer goods. eg: if I eat some food, nobody else can eat the same food.
In my point about teaching, if I consume one hour of a tutor's time, nobody else can consume that same time. But I might fail to learn anything from the tutor, which does not change the fact I consumed that service. Thats why the act of learning itself is not consumption.
"Reading furnishes the mind only with the materials of knowledge; its thinking that make what we read ours."
You pay for college, right?...you paid someone to teach you how to learn and you learned, hopefully, something in return.
If you buy an game or an apt to learn how to play or use that apt then I would consider that an act of consumption also.
Examples in Merriam Webster dictionary: Consumption of resources or The document was not intended for public consumption.
Knowledge, information or facts are resources to be consumed. Just like eating food produces health, (hopefully) and energy. The consumption of information you learn hopefully produces knowledge or a given outcome and perhaps a physical product to be consumed.
However, if you employ teaching services, then they are consumed. Ironically, that is true even if you learn nothing from it.