Does a person have to die to be free?
Posted by edweaver 10 years, 8 months ago to Government
The “Genie, You’re Free” post brought this question to my mind again so thought I would open it to discussion.
Is death the only way to rid yourself of government? When you break it down to this level, is that right?
I don’t intend this to be a morbid discussion nor am I encouraging people to off themselves because of something that may get stated on this topic. Life is still worth living, at least in my opinion but why is death the only way to get that monkey off your back. Is that really the way life is intended. I don’t think so. How do we ever get government out of our lives? What is the better solution?
Is death the only way to rid yourself of government? When you break it down to this level, is that right?
I don’t intend this to be a morbid discussion nor am I encouraging people to off themselves because of something that may get stated on this topic. Life is still worth living, at least in my opinion but why is death the only way to get that monkey off your back. Is that really the way life is intended. I don’t think so. How do we ever get government out of our lives? What is the better solution?
Previous comments... You are currently on page 4.
Do you mean freedom in the sense of no obligations, no need to labor and to do whatever you wish whenever you wish it? If you are a human, there is no way to be totally free in that sense. Besides, you'd probably have the same problem as Adam. You'd be bored and curiosity would get the better of you. However, this does not preclude you from striving to be as free as it is possible. Always there will be obligations keeping you from total freedom; to your loved ones, your job, to yourself, etc. The greatest barrier to human freedom is others telling you what you can and cannot do and forcing you to obey. In an evil society, the use of the law, which should be beneficial is often used to cut away your freedom so that others can have power over you. To answer the question more fully, you are totally free in death, but since you no longer exist, it is a moot point.
You can look at the current nightmare and despair. You ask: “how do ever get the government out of our lives?” Reformulate your question: “how do we restore freedom in America?” It may seem a trivial point, but the first question is akin to: “how do we get the cockroaches out of our kitchen?” It’s a valid question, and the cockroaches have to be eradicated, but it’s mundane and uninspiring. Restoring freedom, on the other hand, inspires, and freedom’s proponents aren’t left just pointing out the deleterious consequences of statism and coercion (even, or especially, for the so-called beneficiaries), but can instead frame the issues in terms of people building better lives for themselves and their families, unobstructed by the state, reaping their just rewards, and rediscovering respect for themselves and their fellow citizens. People need to strive for higher goals than cockroach eradication. (Even that task sounds more palatable if you reformulate it is a part of the job of making your kitchen sparkling clean.)
If we Gulchers frame our goal as restoring freedom, then that can be done in ways large and small. Realize that like all corrupt, overreaching, overextended, overly indebted governments, ours will fail. A big part of our job will be done, but if all we can offer is: “told you so, told you so,” it will not matter. Winston Churchill said, “You can always count on Americans to do the right thing—after they’ve tried everything else.” After the collapse, many Americans will be ready to try the right thing: restoring freedom. The government will be bankrupt and continuation of the welfare state and foreign adventurism will be fiscally impossible. But intellectual revolutions always precede actual revolutions, so it is now that we must make the case not just against current arrangements, but the positive case for restoring freedom, in every way that we can. That’s what leaders do.
Only while there is life can you still make your mark in the world, add a stepping stone to humanity's future. Never give up of your own free will. Live for your own life. Give no one control of your mind. The mind IS free.
We live in the days we live in. Little to be done about that.
But the future is ours. Manifest Destiny all over again.
Work toward new, independent, city-states at sea or in space.
Both Aristotle and Socrates wrote and spoke of death and spiritual freedom, but one must remember the were both soldiers, and a certain expectation of death is common enough.
Friedrich Nietzsche " theorized that in order to truly "live" a realistic confrontation with death was required."
But is death truly death, no one really knows . . .
Of course, I am guilty of fat-thumbing like crazy, but at least it's not like my old one where I had to type with my pinkies... You can also adjust the font and color scheme - makes it easier to read what you wrote...
Now, we have big government. And it seems the more government, the more oppressive anti-business said government becomes... and the more power it grabs, the larger the dragon becomes.
No, big government is there for one purpose - to make itself bigger, and to skim the hard work of the producers off into the pockets of the moochers participating in said government.