AI for Dummies: AI Turns Us Into Dummies
Posted by freedomforall 1 week, 6 days ago to Technology
Excerpt:
"The point here is those who received real educations can use AI because they know enough to double-check it, but the kids using AI as a substitute for real learning will never develop this capacity.
Those who actually have mastery can use AI and not realize the point I'm making isn't that AI is useless, the point is it fatally undermines real learning and thinking.
The MIT paper is 206 pages long, the last section being the stats of the research, but the points it makes are truly important. So is the other article linked below.
That AI is turning those who use it into dummies is not only self-evident, it's irrefutable. ChatGPT May Be Eroding Critical Thinking Skills, According to a New MIT Study
https://time.com/7295195/ai-chatgpt-g...
"Of the three groups, ChatGPT users had the lowest brain engagement and 'consistently underperformed at neural, linguistic, and behavioral levels.' Over the course of several months, ChatGPT users got lazier with each subsequent essay, often resorting to copy-and-paste by the end of the study.
"The task was executed, and you could say that it was efficient and convenient," Kosmyna says. "But as we show in the paper, you basically didn't integrate any of it into your memory networks.""
"The point here is those who received real educations can use AI because they know enough to double-check it, but the kids using AI as a substitute for real learning will never develop this capacity.
Those who actually have mastery can use AI and not realize the point I'm making isn't that AI is useless, the point is it fatally undermines real learning and thinking.
The MIT paper is 206 pages long, the last section being the stats of the research, but the points it makes are truly important. So is the other article linked below.
That AI is turning those who use it into dummies is not only self-evident, it's irrefutable. ChatGPT May Be Eroding Critical Thinking Skills, According to a New MIT Study
https://time.com/7295195/ai-chatgpt-g...
"Of the three groups, ChatGPT users had the lowest brain engagement and 'consistently underperformed at neural, linguistic, and behavioral levels.' Over the course of several months, ChatGPT users got lazier with each subsequent essay, often resorting to copy-and-paste by the end of the study.
"The task was executed, and you could say that it was efficient and convenient," Kosmyna says. "But as we show in the paper, you basically didn't integrate any of it into your memory networks.""
What is lacking today are critical thinking skills!
Is it Live or Is it Memorex? - SAVVY STREET,
But then, when I was a kid I didn't play with dolls. They weren't alive, so why bother? This did not go over well with some of my grandchildren, because try as I might, I simply couldn't play dolls with them. (I am not bragging about that - it's one of my bigger failures, IMO.)
But what I've found is that in order to get a good answer, I have to ask a good question. And in that aspect, AI hasn't completely failed me, thank goodness. I have lost count of the times that I tried to form a question for AI, only to realize that I knew the answer (or was able to discern it) before I finished the question. Also, AI has been good for inadvertently pointing out to me the parts of the question I left out, as it formulated the answer for me.
Now about that math-on-paper and in-the-head...that's where I have allowed myself to be dumbed down. Sometimes getting that active with formulating a reasonable math answer seems harder than it used to be. I don't know whether that's old age or AI. In either case, the answer is the same: Practice.
Not quite sure how I allowed myself to get so off-track, but the entire topic is pretty interesting. And just because it's something that in many ways we don't "like," I refuse to ignore it. I am quite sure that long after the first highway was built, people were ignoring cars in favor of horse-and-buggy tech. They probably thought if they ignored cars long enough, they'd go away.
The only thing I've EVER discovered that will "go away" when you ignore them......is your teeth. That's pretty much guaranteed.
It's also seems to be very bad with biographical details. It not only had my friend of long ago shoot himself months after his death, but it killed Tom Lehrer by having him die this past April rather than in July.
Use AI for fun and for speed. It does indeed catch some things we might have missed, but don't trust it except for production of solid nonsense, and even then inspect the results.
Do I have that right???
On the other hand, innovation supplants the old with the new with often wonderful results. American farmers have mostly lost the skill to plow with oxen or horses because it is so convenient and profitable to climb aboard a tractor.
We'll see what happens with AI, I guess.